How to Get More Therapy Clients: What to Do First

If you're trying to get more therapy clients, you've probably already been told to update your Psychology Today profile, improve your SEO, post more on social media, start networking, and maybe try Google Ads.

Oh, and don't forget to write blog posts.

Apparently, running a private practice now requires a second full-time job in marketing. Fun!

But after years of helping therapists grow their businesses, one of the biggest things I've noticed is that therapists are often putting a lot of effort into fixing the wrong problem.

They're trying to get more people to a website that doesn't connect with potential clients. They're posting on Instagram when their best referrals have always come from other professionals. Or they're getting people to contact them, but those people never end up scheduling.

And sometimes they're already seeing plenty of clients. They're just not making enough money from the sessions they're providing.

So before you spend another weekend researching marketing strategies (or finally convince yourself to make those Instagram reels you've been avoiding), I want you to look at what's happening in your practice.

The best way to get more therapy clients is to identify what's preventing people from finding, contacting, or scheduling with you, then focus on improving that part of your business.

Here's how I'd approach it.

1. Figure Out How Many More Therapy Clients You Need

I know. You came here looking for ways to get more clients, and I'm starting with numbers.

But stay with me.

One of the first things I ask therapists is how many additional clients they need to reach their income goals.

Because having 7 openings in your schedule doesn't necessarily mean you need 7 new clients.

If most of your clients attend every other week, you could need approximately 14 additional clients to consistently fill those 7 weekly appointment slots.

And that's before considering cancellations, vacations, and clients completing treatment.

A therapist who provides short-term treatment may need new clients more frequently than someone whose clients typically stay for a year or longer.

Before deciding how much marketing you need to do, look at:

  • Your monthly income goal and current income.

  • Your average collected fee per session, especially if you accept insurance.

  • The number of sessions you're providing each week.

  • How many additional appointments your schedule can accommodate.

  • How frequently clients attend and how long they typically stay in treatment.

What if your income is too low but your caseload is full?

This is why I don't automatically recommend getting more clients.

If you're already seeing 25–30 clients a week and you're exhausted, adding another 5 appointments probably isn't going to improve your situation.

Instead, I'd look at your average session revenue, insurance reimbursements, fees, schedule, and services.

For example, increasing your average collected revenue by $10 across 25 weekly sessions would add $250 per week, or approximately $11,500 over 46 working weeks.

That doesn't mean you can raise every reimbursement rate tomorrow. But gradual changes to your rates or service mix may be more sustainable than adding hours.

Start here: Calculate how many additional clients or sessions you need to reach your income goal. Make sure getting more clients is the problem you need to solve.

2. Find Out Where Your Recent Therapy Clients Came From

Here's a question I ask therapists all the time:

Where did your last 5–10 clients come from?

And a surprising number can't tell me.

They remember that a couple came through Psychology Today, someone was referred by another therapist, and a few found them online.

But that's usually about as specific as it gets.

When we dig into those numbers, we often find something useful.

Maybe most of their private-pay clients came from 2 referral partners. Or Psychology Today generates plenty of contacts, but very few people schedule.

Those situations tell us different things about what needs attention.

Look beyond where someone found your name

Let's say someone tells you they found you on Google.

Did they search for "therapist near me"?

Did they search for someone who treats postpartum anxiety?

Or did they search for your name after their OB-GYN recommended you?

That last person might technically have found your website through Google, but a professional referral was probably what prompted them to contact you.

When possible, ask people how they first heard about you and what made them decide to reach out.

Then start tracking how many new contacts you receive, where they came from, how many consultations get scheduled, and how many people become clients.

You don't need a complicated system. A spreadsheet works fine.

More contacts don't necessarily mean better results

Imagine Psychology Today generates 12 contacts in a month, but only 2 become clients.

Meanwhile, a referral partner sends 3 people, and all 3 schedule.

I wouldn't automatically tell you to abandon Psychology Today. I'd want to know why those other contacts aren't becoming clients.

Are they looking for a service you don't provide? Do your fees or availability not match their needs? Are they having trouble scheduling?

And I'd also want to understand what makes that referral partner so effective.

Start here: Review your last 5–10 clients and begin tracking what happens between someone contacting your practice and becoming a client.

3. Make Your Niche and Messaging More Specific

I know some therapists are probably tired of hearing about niching.

And I get it. You don't want to turn away someone you could help just because they don't fit into a perfectly defined category.

But being more specific about who you want to work with doesn't mean you're forbidden from seeing anyone else.

It helps the people you especially want to work with recognize that you understand their problems.

For example, let's say your website says:

"I help women struggling with anxiety, depression, and life transitions."

Now think about these women:

  • A new mother experiencing intrusive thoughts who is afraid to tell anyone.

  • A mother whose child has significant medical needs and who worries constantly about what could happen next.

  • A woman whose children have moved out and who feels disconnected from the life she's spent years building.

All 3 may be experiencing anxiety.

But their daily problems, the words they'd use to describe them, and where they'd look for support are very different.

If your website only talks about anxiety in broad terms, you're missing opportunities to show people that you understand their particular situation.

Stop making your credentials do all the work

I've reviewed plenty of therapist websites that spend several paragraphs explaining certifications, modalities, and treatment approaches.

And somewhere near the bottom, there's a sentence about who the therapist helps.

Your training matters. I'm certainly not suggesting you hide it.

But someone who's lying awake at 3 AM worrying about their baby probably isn't starting their search by comparing graduate programs.

They're trying to find someone who understands what they're going through.

Your website and directory profiles should help them recognize that.

And your niche should influence more than your copy. It should also help you identify where potential clients are looking for support and which professionals might be valuable referral partners.

For example, a therapist specializing in pregnancy and postpartum anxiety has a reason to build relationships with OB-GYNs, doulas, midwives, and lactation consultants.

That's a much better starting point than randomly emailing every doctor's office within 20 miles.

Start here: Read your homepage and Psychology Today profile. Would someone in your intended audience recognize their specific problems, or would they mainly learn about your credentials?

4. Look at What You're Calling Marketing

This is one of my favorite things to investigate with clients because it's where we often discover they're spending more time thinking about marketing than doing activities that could bring in clients.

And I say that with plenty of personal understanding. I've absolutely spent time researching how to do something when I could've just done the thing.

A therapist will tell me they've spent hours marketing that week.

So I'll ask what they did.

They scrolled through Facebook groups, checked referral requests, researched SEO, saved some Instagram ideas, and thought about updating their website.

Maybe they spent 2 hours deciding whether to start a blog.

But did any of that help someone new discover their practice?

Track the activities, not just the hours

For one week, write down exactly what you're doing.

There's a difference between "worked on marketing for 2 hours" and "contacted 3 potential referral partners, followed up with 2 people, and updated my homepage."

Research and planning are useful. But if you've spent 3 weeks researching how to improve your Psychology Today profile and haven't changed a single sentence, we have a problem.

You don't have to use Instagram

I have nothing against Instagram when it's working for someone.

But I've seen therapists force themselves to post because they think that's what marketing is supposed to look like.

They don't enjoy it, they're not sure their potential clients are there, and they haven't gotten meaningful results.

Meanwhile, they haven't followed up with the professional who offered to introduce them to 2 potential referral partners.

That doesn't make much sense to me.

Your marketing should be based on who you're trying to reach, where those people are, and which activities you can realistically do consistently.

If you want to explore some other approaches, I've written about 5 ways to get noticed by your ideal clients, including building your network, pursuing visibility opportunities, and creating processes that make marketing easier to maintain.

Start here: Write down the marketing activities you've completed recently. Identify which ones have helped potential clients or referral partners learn about your services.

5. Build Referral Relationships Instead of Waiting for Referrals

One thing I see therapists do is respond to every referral request in a Facebook group or professional listserv.

Someone posts that they're looking for a therapist, and 15 people respond with some version of:

"I'm accepting clients! Here's my website!"

Sometimes that works.

But if you're responding to requests regardless of whether you're a good match, you're making more work for the person trying to refer someone.

I'd rather see you become someone a smaller group of professionals thinks of when a particular kind of client needs help.

Start with professionals who serve the same audience

If you help children whose parents are going through a divorce, divorce attorneys and mediators might be valuable people to know.

They regularly work with families who may need support, and you can help them understand when therapy could be useful.

But please don't send a generic flyer, wait 2 weeks, and decide referral marketing doesn't work because nobody sent you a client.

Building a referral relationship means learning about someone's work, understanding the clients they serve, and finding ways to be useful to each other.

You might share information, make introductions, answer questions about your specialty, or connect them with other resources.

And you need to follow up.

A therapist sends an introductory email, doesn't hear back, and decides outreach isn't working.

But think about how many emails you receive and don't answer immediately, even when you're interested.

A thoughtful follow-up is reasonable.

Once someone responds, you still need to develop the relationship. That means staying in touch after your first conversation instead of disappearing until your calendar has openings again.

You can be meeting new professionals, following up with previous contacts, and maintaining existing relationships at the same time.

Start here: Identify 3–5 professionals who work with your ideal clients. Begin with people you already know, and reach out with an interest in learning about their work rather than just announcing your availability.

6. Check Whether People Are Reaching Out but Not Scheduling

This is a big one.

If very few people are contacting your practice, we need to look at your visibility and messaging.

But if people are contacting you and aren't scheduling, doing more marketing may just bring more people into a process that's already losing them.

I've seen therapists make scheduling much more complicated than it needs to be.

Someone fills out a contact form. The therapist emails asking about availability. The person sends 3 possible times. None work. The therapist sends another email.

Now we're 4 emails into scheduling a 15-minute consultation.

And the person disappears.

As someone with ADHD, I can tell you that coordinating multiple emails and calendars can be enough to make me put something off, even when it's something I really want.

Imagine how that process might feel to someone who's already overwhelmed and struggling to ask for help.

Make the next step easier

I'd look at your entire process, starting with the contact form.

Are you asking for information you need, or making someone complete a lengthy questionnaire before you've even spoken?

How quickly are you responding?

Can someone easily schedule a consultation or first appointment?

Are your fees, services, and availability explained?

What happens if someone doesn't respond to your first message?

And what happens after a consultation when someone says yes, no, or maybe?

You don't necessarily need an online scheduler. But you do need a process that makes it reasonably easy for someone to move forward.

There's research supporting the importance of this stage. A 2021 systematic review of 34 studies on initial psychological therapy appointments identified barriers involving service responsiveness, flexibility, and people's concerns about beginning treatment.

That doesn't mean every person who doesn't schedule would have become a client if you'd followed up. But it gives us another reason to examine the process instead of assuming you simply need more people contacting you.

Don't assume no response means no interest

Sometimes therapists send one email, don't hear back, and assume the person changed their mind.

Maybe they did.

But maybe they're overwhelmed, missed the email, or meant to respond and forgot.

A thoughtful follow-up once or twice, when appropriate, can give someone another opportunity to reconnect without pressure.

Start here: Walk through your contact and scheduling process as though you're a potential client. Look for unnecessary steps, delays, or places where someone could easily drop off.

7. Review Your Website and Directory Profiles Before Paying for More Traffic

I've seen therapists spend thousands of dollars on websites that look beautiful but don't do a particularly good job of helping someone decide whether to contact them.

Sometimes the designer did exactly what they were hired to do. They built an attractive website.

But that doesn't mean the messaging connects with the therapist's intended audience.

And hiring someone to improve your SEO doesn't automatically solve that problem either.

You could get more website visitors without getting more clients.

Start with the information people need

When someone visits your homepage or Psychology Today profile, can they quickly tell who you help?

Do you describe the problems they're experiencing in words they'd recognize?

Is it obvious how to contact you?

Are your services, fees, locations, and availability information accurate?

If you're not happy with the answers, you may not need a complete redesign.

You might need to rewrite the homepage, update the description of your services, or make scheduling easier.

Those are much more manageable projects.

And if you're working with a designer or SEO professional, you still need to bring your knowledge of your clients into the process.

Nobody understands the people you work with better than you do.

If you're ready to work on bringing more potential clients to your website, I've also written about 10 ways to get your ideal clients to your website.

Start here: Review your homepage and primary directory profile. Choose 1–2 changes that would make it easier for someone to understand your services and contact you.

8. Decide What to Fix First Based on Your Situation

At this point, you might have a list of things you want to change.

Your website needs work. You haven't contacted referral partners in months. Your Psychology Today profile is outdated. You probably need a better way to track where clients come from.

And now you've got another overwhelming to-do list.

Which is exactly what I don't want you to walk away with.

The order depends on what's happening in your practice.

If hardly anyone is contacting you

I'd start with your niche, messaging, visibility, and existing referral sources.

Are enough people learning about your practice? Are they the people you want to work with? Do they have a reason to contact you?

Choose a few specific activities to improve your visibility while making sure your messaging connects with your intended audience.

If people are contacting you but not scheduling

I'd look at the information they're receiving and your intake process.

Are they looking for services you don't provide? Are there scheduling delays? Are they contacting you expecting something different from what you offer?

I wouldn't automatically recommend spending money to attract more people before understanding why the ones already contacting you aren't scheduling.

If you need 5 new clients soon

I'd look at where your recent clients came from and which existing relationships or marketing activities could produce results sooner.

Maybe you need to reconnect with referral partners, update your directory profile, or increase the time you spend on activities that have worked before.

You can build referral relationships while improving your website.

You don't have to finish a 6-week website redesign before you're allowed to send an email to someone who could refer clients.

If you're starting a new private practice

You may need more time to establish the foundations of your business.

That could include developing your niche and messaging, setting up your website or directory profiles, establishing your intake process, and building your referral network.

Someone who already has those things in place may need much less setup time.

How many hours should you spend marketing each week?

I don't have a universal minimum.

It depends on how many clients and how much income you need, how long you've been struggling, what you've tried, and what assets your practice already has.

It also depends on your strengths and which activities make sense for your business.

If you have 7 unfilled appointment slots next week, you may have several hours you could dedicate to business development.

But I wouldn't tell you to spend those hours randomly posting on social media.

I'd want you to schedule activities based on what your practice needs and what you've learned about where clients come from.

Start here: Identify the problem most likely affecting your client flow and choose 2–3 specific actions you can realistically complete in the next week.

9. Keep Doing What Works When Your Caseload Is Full

I know it's difficult to think about ongoing marketing when you're currently trying to get more clients.

But this is one of the patterns I see repeatedly.

A therapist's calendar fills up, so marketing drops to the bottom of the list.

They're seeing clients, writing notes, managing insurance, and trying to have a life outside work.

Then a few clients finish treatment, someone moves, and referrals slow down.

Suddenly, there are more openings than expected, and the therapist has to start rebuilding their marketing activity.

You don't need to market at the same intensity all year.

But I do want you to continue the activities that have been working.

Maybe that's maintaining referral relationships, sending useful emails, publishing occasional articles, or keeping your directory profiles current.

The specific activities will depend on your practice.

The important thing is having a way to keep them going even when you're busy.

Start here: Identify which effective marketing activities you'll continue when your caseload is full, and make room for them in your schedule.

Want Help Figuring Out Which Part of Your Marketing Needs Attention?

If you've been trying different things to get more therapy clients and aren't sure what to focus on, I have a free resource that can help.

The Consistent Clients Fix includes a quick self-check covering your niche and messaging, referral relationships, and marketing consistency, along with practical actions you can start taking this week.

GET THE FREE CONSISTENT CLIENTS FIX →

Frequently Asked Questions About Getting More Therapy Clients

How can I get more therapy clients without social media?

You can build a private practice through professional referral relationships, directories, community connections, your website, and other ways of reaching potential clients.

Start by looking at where your recent clients came from and which activities make sense for your specialty and strengths. You don't need to force yourself onto every social media platform.

Why am I not getting clients from Psychology Today?

It could be a visibility problem, a messaging problem, or something happening after people contact you.

Look at whether your profile is generating contacts, whether those people are a good match for your services, and how many schedule appointments.

Then review your description, specialties, availability, and contact process.

How long does it take to fill a private practice?

There's no single timeline.

Your specialty, location, fees, insurance participation, professional relationships, schedule, and marketing activities all affect how quickly your caseload grows.

Rather than comparing yourself with another therapist, track your own progress and where your clients are coming from.

Do I need a website to get therapy clients?

No. You can get clients through professional referrals and other sources without a website.

But a website can make it easier for potential clients to learn about your services and contact you.

If you don't have one yet, you can begin building referral relationships while establishing your online presence.

Should I use Google Ads to get more therapy clients?

Possibly, but I'd review your current marketing and finances first.

If you're spending $1,000 a month on advertising, that's $12,000 a year your practice needs to cover before the advertising contributes to your income.

I'd want to know whether your messaging connects with potential clients, your scheduling process works, and you're tracking whether contacts from ads become clients.

What's the fastest way to get more therapy clients?

There's no one method that's fastest for every therapist.

If you need clients soon, start by reviewing the sources that have brought you clients recently, reconnecting with existing referral partners, checking your current website and directory messaging, and making it easy for interested people to schedule.

Developing an entirely new marketing channel can take time, so don't overlook what you've already built.

Getting More Therapy Clients Starts With Knowing What Needs Attention

When your calendar has more openings than you want, it's tempting to assume there's another marketing strategy you should be trying.

Another directory. Another social media platform. Another website update.

But sometimes the problem is much more specific.

Maybe your referral partners don't know what kinds of clients you're looking for. Maybe your website describes your credentials beautifully but barely mentions the problems your clients are experiencing. Maybe people are contacting you, but scheduling is harder than it needs to be.

Or maybe you're seeing plenty of clients and need to address your average session revenue instead of adding more appointments.

That's why I want you to look at what's happening in your practice before deciding what to do next.

You may need more visibility, better messaging, stronger referral relationships, or a simpler scheduling process.

You don't have to tackle all of those things this week.

Start with the ones that are affecting your business.

Want Help Figuring Out What to Prioritize?

This is the work I do with therapists through my 1:1 business coaching.

We look at where your clients are coming from, what's happening with your marketing, how people move from contacting you to scheduling, and what your practice needs to earn.

Then we work on changes that make sense for your business, rather than adding more marketing activities you don't have time for.

If you'd like help getting more consistent clients and income, you can learn more about working together here.

Next
Next

How to Raise Your Prices Without Second-Guessing Yourself